Re: 洗脫污名:談僑生正名的意義 - 馬來西亞
By Ina
at 2008-07-25T01:41
at 2008-07-25T01:41
Table of Contents
→ Realthugz:會拿三二來說嘴的應該是白目啊 何必跟豬在泥巴裡打架? 07/24 23:48
→ Realthugz:可是要是有不少人因為靠三二才畢業 誰該檢討? 07/24 23:48
→ yangthang:你應該清楚是為什吧?又何須我來回答。 07/24 23:58
→ yangthang:你太概沒遇到過有人大一的時候被差點被三二,可是後來 07/24 23:59
→ yangthang:努力用功,順利拿到好成積畢業。 07/25 00:00
→ yangthang:我大一的物理老師,他去美國留學,剛到的時候成積太爛, 07/25 00:01
→ yangthang:他差點就打道回府了,所以他對我說他一直可以理解成積不 07/25 00:02
→ yangthang:不好僑生的心情。 07/25 00:03
→ yangthang:大一、二的時候我不敢說我是僑生,因為成積太爛,每次老 07/25 00:05
推 Realthugz:我大學也二一過一次 最後還是順利考上研究所 07/25 00:05
→ Realthugz:不知道情況有像嗎? XD 人總有低潮時阿 07/25 00:05
→ yangthang:老師問問題,答不出來,同學都會幫我說,我是僑生。 07/25 00:05
→ yangthang:現在不用同學幫我說,我自已就會大聲的說出來我是僑生 07/25 00:06
→ yangthang:人只要努力總會有機會讓妳抬頭挺胸的時候。 07/25 00:10
Y網友、R網友,你們混淆整個爭議的焦點了。
C網友、L網友等人今天在這裡談歧視、污名化、正名等,
重點並不在探討誰人受到了歧視,誰人遭受不公平待遇,誰人又努力讓僑生名號發光發熱
雖然這些都是事實,都是每個人的真實遭遇。
而且老實說,我相信大部份的人偶爾被問是不是加分進大學以外,
其在台灣的大學生活應該都是快樂充實,而且結交到許多要好的台灣朋友,
但這都不是這裡討論的重點,現在不是來比較誰被歧視得比較深,誰如何活得更自在,
C網友、L網友都不是在說明這些東西。
他們不是在談你遇到了什麼事情,也不是探討如何努力讓僑生在歧視中抬頭挺胸,
甚至也不是爭辯僑生有沒有遇到歧視,或到底有沒有存在歧視。
L網友的觀點是,我們都不具有中華民國國籍,所以我們不是僑生,也不應該是僑生;
而C網友一直以來所批判的,是台灣這個社會對僑生的「集體想象」,
簡單講,就是台灣人對「僑生」的刻板印象。
所以,在這樣的討論裡,
若單純只以個人的角度回應「我沒有受到歧視,所以沒有歧視」,
或「只要努力抬頭挺胸,就不會被歧視」,那也只是淪為個人之間的比較,
無助於釐清僑生狀況整體性的問題,
現在是探討「僑生留學」這個制度、政策、以及刻板印像的議題,
不是在探討你個人作為僑生遇到什麼問題,也不是分享你對僑生身份是否認同或有何感受
你明白我說什麼嗎 = =?
--
Tags:
馬來西亞
All Comments
By Carol
at 2008-07-29T19:28
at 2008-07-29T19:28
By Kama
at 2008-08-03T07:38
at 2008-08-03T07:38
By Elizabeth
at 2008-08-03T13:13
at 2008-08-03T13:13
By Gilbert
at 2008-08-04T18:24
at 2008-08-04T18:24
By Franklin
at 2008-08-06T04:45
at 2008-08-06T04:45
By Ula
at 2008-08-07T09:04
at 2008-08-07T09:04
By Carol
at 2008-08-11T19:39
at 2008-08-11T19:39
By Zenobia
at 2008-08-16T05:23
at 2008-08-16T05:23
By Ursula
at 2008-08-20T15:35
at 2008-08-20T15:35
By Suhail Hany
at 2008-08-24T10:23
at 2008-08-24T10:23
By Todd Johnson
at 2008-08-27T12:31
at 2008-08-27T12:31
By Tracy
at 2008-08-30T17:43
at 2008-08-30T17:43
By Jacky
at 2008-08-30T22:26
at 2008-08-30T22:26
By Ida
at 2008-09-03T04:35
at 2008-09-03T04:35
By Erin
at 2008-09-04T21:11
at 2008-09-04T21:11
By Heather
at 2008-09-09T08:17
at 2008-09-09T08:17
By Ingrid
at 2008-09-10T21:04
at 2008-09-10T21:04
By Todd Johnson
at 2008-09-13T21:06
at 2008-09-13T21:06
By Emily
at 2008-09-18T04:08
at 2008-09-18T04:08
By Skylar DavisLinda
at 2008-09-19T07:45
at 2008-09-19T07:45
By Jacky
at 2008-09-23T13:29
at 2008-09-23T13:29
By Doris
at 2008-09-27T22:07
at 2008-09-27T22:07
By Kelly
at 2008-10-01T12:59
at 2008-10-01T12:59
By Edward Lewis
at 2008-10-02T13:40
at 2008-10-02T13:40
By Leila
at 2008-10-03T10:29
at 2008-10-03T10:29
By Charlotte
at 2008-10-06T10:29
at 2008-10-06T10:29
By Queena
at 2008-10-10T10:07
at 2008-10-10T10:07
By Callum
at 2008-10-10T13:29
at 2008-10-10T13:29
By Freda
at 2008-10-14T22:45
at 2008-10-14T22:45
By Liam
at 2008-10-17T18:19
at 2008-10-17T18:19
By Carol
at 2008-10-19T08:09
at 2008-10-19T08:09
By Agatha
at 2008-10-21T04:59
at 2008-10-21T04:59
By Una
at 2008-10-23T17:01
at 2008-10-23T17:01
By Brianna
at 2008-10-28T16:23
at 2008-10-28T16:23
By Harry
at 2008-10-29T21:45
at 2008-10-29T21:45
By Isla
at 2008-11-02T17:49
at 2008-11-02T17:49
By Candice
at 2008-11-04T08:20
at 2008-11-04T08:20
By Candice
at 2008-11-08T23:27
at 2008-11-08T23:27
By James
at 2008-11-10T02:17
at 2008-11-10T02:17
By Mason
at 2008-11-11T10:48
at 2008-11-11T10:48
By Ula
at 2008-11-12T12:51
at 2008-11-12T12:51
By Enid
at 2008-11-12T23:55
at 2008-11-12T23:55
By Ivy
at 2008-11-14T01:45
at 2008-11-14T01:45
By Puput
at 2008-11-17T15:11
at 2008-11-17T15:11
By Yedda
at 2008-11-18T13:28
at 2008-11-18T13:28
By Jessica
at 2008-11-21T03:19
at 2008-11-21T03:19
By Rosalind
at 2008-11-21T12:10
at 2008-11-21T12:10
Related Posts
Re: 洗脫污名:談僑生正名的意義
By Aaliyah
at 2008-07-24T23:46
at 2008-07-24T23:46
馬來西亞幣
By Susan
at 2008-07-24T22:50
at 2008-07-24T22:50
Re: 洗脫污名:談僑生正名的意義
By Quintina
at 2008-07-24T14:32
at 2008-07-24T14:32
ST.MICHAEL 這間中學在哪裡?
By Genevieve
at 2008-07-24T13:44
at 2008-07-24T13:44
ST.MICHAEL 這間中學在哪裡?
By Joe
at 2008-07-24T12:23
at 2008-07-24T12:23