[論卦] 加拿大不承認台灣是中國領土的理由 - 加拿大
By Zora
at 2008-05-07T13:06
at 2008-05-07T13:06
Table of Contents
※ [本文轉錄自 Gossiping 看板]
作者: ohfly (像個小孩子) 看板: Gossiping
標題: [論卦] 加拿大不承認台灣是中國領土的理由
時間: Wed May 7 12:09:08 2008
加拿大, 全球政治最清廉的國家之一
加拿大外交部的回答讓我們不得不佩服....
長久以來,中國一直堅持台灣是中國的一部份。但是在60年代,中共便為此鬧了個國際笑
話。中國外交部要求加拿大承認台灣是中國的領土。加拿大提出5點理由反駁﹕
(一)台灣並非加拿大所擁有之領土,所以加拿大沒有權利承認台灣主權歸屬於誰。
如果是加拿大所擁有的北極圈諸小島與中國有爭議,加拿大才有權利承認其歸屬。這是從
羅馬法以來的所有權法理。國際法當然也依此原則適用。
(二)沒有任何國際法理論使加拿大有「權利」承認、或有「義務」承認與它無任何關係
的台灣的主權歸屬。中國要求加拿大做這種承認毫無道理。
(三)即使加拿大承認台灣是中國一部份,實際上並無任何法效果或意義。因為加拿大國
民、飛機、船舶要進入台灣,拿北京政權所發簽證根本無效,還是要向台灣當局申請簽證
。承認其對台灣實效統治,這等於是立刻又以具體行為否認台灣是中國的一部份。
(四)加拿大若在國際條約中承認台灣是中國的一部份,依條約必須履行原理,加拿大勢
必派兵攻佔台灣,負責把台灣交給中國以履行條約。這是多麼荒謬的一件事。
(五)台灣如果的確屬於中國,則北京政權又何必要求各國承認。例如,海南島是中國領
土不可分割的一部份,中國根本不必要求他國承認。反之,台灣若非中國領土,中國即使
到處去要求他國承認,實際上也沒有國際法效果。如果台灣是有紛爭的領土,中國也應該
去找與該領土有關的當事國交涉及承認才有國際法效果。強迫無關的第三國承認是毫無意
義。
說得中國外交部啞口無言,十億口莫辨。自此之後,中國只能嘴巴嚷嚷,不敢再要求加拿
大承認台灣是中國的領土。
論理充分...提出理由的加拿大外交部老兄顯然受過嚴謹邏輯訓練... ...
--
作者: ohfly (像個小孩子) 看板: Gossiping
標題: [論卦] 加拿大不承認台灣是中國領土的理由
時間: Wed May 7 12:09:08 2008
加拿大, 全球政治最清廉的國家之一
加拿大外交部的回答讓我們不得不佩服....
長久以來,中國一直堅持台灣是中國的一部份。但是在60年代,中共便為此鬧了個國際笑
話。中國外交部要求加拿大承認台灣是中國的領土。加拿大提出5點理由反駁﹕
(一)台灣並非加拿大所擁有之領土,所以加拿大沒有權利承認台灣主權歸屬於誰。
如果是加拿大所擁有的北極圈諸小島與中國有爭議,加拿大才有權利承認其歸屬。這是從
羅馬法以來的所有權法理。國際法當然也依此原則適用。
(二)沒有任何國際法理論使加拿大有「權利」承認、或有「義務」承認與它無任何關係
的台灣的主權歸屬。中國要求加拿大做這種承認毫無道理。
(三)即使加拿大承認台灣是中國一部份,實際上並無任何法效果或意義。因為加拿大國
民、飛機、船舶要進入台灣,拿北京政權所發簽證根本無效,還是要向台灣當局申請簽證
。承認其對台灣實效統治,這等於是立刻又以具體行為否認台灣是中國的一部份。
(四)加拿大若在國際條約中承認台灣是中國的一部份,依條約必須履行原理,加拿大勢
必派兵攻佔台灣,負責把台灣交給中國以履行條約。這是多麼荒謬的一件事。
(五)台灣如果的確屬於中國,則北京政權又何必要求各國承認。例如,海南島是中國領
土不可分割的一部份,中國根本不必要求他國承認。反之,台灣若非中國領土,中國即使
到處去要求他國承認,實際上也沒有國際法效果。如果台灣是有紛爭的領土,中國也應該
去找與該領土有關的當事國交涉及承認才有國際法效果。強迫無關的第三國承認是毫無意
義。
說得中國外交部啞口無言,十億口莫辨。自此之後,中國只能嘴巴嚷嚷,不敢再要求加拿
大承認台灣是中國的領土。
論理充分...提出理由的加拿大外交部老兄顯然受過嚴謹邏輯訓練... ...
--
Tags:
加拿大
All Comments
By Daph Bay
at 2008-05-11T02:18
at 2008-05-11T02:18
By Jessica
at 2008-05-15T15:29
at 2008-05-15T15:29
By Edward Lewis
at 2008-05-19T20:19
at 2008-05-19T20:19
By Edwina
at 2008-05-23T05:00
at 2008-05-23T05:00
By Daniel
at 2008-05-23T19:54
at 2008-05-23T19:54
By Eden
at 2008-05-27T14:20
at 2008-05-27T14:20
By Andrew
at 2008-05-27T17:26
at 2008-05-27T17:26
By Lily
at 2008-05-28T12:36
at 2008-05-28T12:36
By Susan
at 2008-05-28T19:08
at 2008-05-28T19:08
By Rae
at 2008-06-02T14:47
at 2008-06-02T14:47
By William
at 2008-06-04T05:42
at 2008-06-04T05:42
By Rae
at 2008-06-06T23:15
at 2008-06-06T23:15
By Genevieve
at 2008-06-08T14:14
at 2008-06-08T14:14
By Jake
at 2008-06-10T03:45
at 2008-06-10T03:45
By Skylar Davis
at 2008-06-11T10:55
at 2008-06-11T10:55
By Daniel
at 2008-06-11T15:29
at 2008-06-11T15:29
By Carolina Franco
at 2008-06-11T16:34
at 2008-06-11T16:34
By Ina
at 2008-06-14T19:06
at 2008-06-14T19:06
By Xanthe
at 2008-06-18T02:00
at 2008-06-18T02:00
By Rachel
at 2008-06-19T21:15
at 2008-06-19T21:15
By Olive
at 2008-06-22T16:31
at 2008-06-22T16:31
By Linda
at 2008-06-25T11:27
at 2008-06-25T11:27
By Quintina
at 2008-06-26T09:11
at 2008-06-26T09:11
By Eartha
at 2008-06-26T16:05
at 2008-06-26T16:05
By Ina
at 2008-06-30T19:36
at 2008-06-30T19:36
By Hedwig
at 2008-07-03T06:11
at 2008-07-03T06:11
By Victoria
at 2008-07-04T02:58
at 2008-07-04T02:58
By Kumar
at 2008-07-08T16:23
at 2008-07-08T16:23
By Liam
at 2008-07-09T18:38
at 2008-07-09T18:38
By Rachel
at 2008-07-11T08:53
at 2008-07-11T08:53
By Olive
at 2008-07-12T07:41
at 2008-07-12T07:41
By Brianna
at 2008-07-16T18:22
at 2008-07-16T18:22
By Noah
at 2008-07-19T10:29
at 2008-07-19T10:29
By Anonymous
at 2008-07-21T04:32
at 2008-07-21T04:32
By Anonymous
at 2008-07-23T17:22
at 2008-07-23T17:22
By Frederica
at 2008-07-27T11:47
at 2008-07-27T11:47
By Annie
at 2008-07-29T04:40
at 2008-07-29T04:40
By Isabella
at 2008-08-01T02:53
at 2008-08-01T02:53
By Catherine
at 2008-08-05T08:32
at 2008-08-05T08:32
By Harry
at 2008-08-09T07:23
at 2008-08-09T07:23
By Kyle
at 2008-08-10T16:35
at 2008-08-10T16:35
By Ida
at 2008-08-12T01:29
at 2008-08-12T01:29
By Liam
at 2008-08-15T08:24
at 2008-08-15T08:24
By Michael
at 2008-08-19T06:35
at 2008-08-19T06:35
By Yuri
at 2008-08-19T23:35
at 2008-08-19T23:35
By Eartha
at 2008-08-20T23:16
at 2008-08-20T23:16
By Valerie
at 2008-08-24T08:45
at 2008-08-24T08:45
By Lauren
at 2008-08-26T04:05
at 2008-08-26T04:05
By Elma
at 2008-08-28T17:15
at 2008-08-28T17:15
By Sarah
at 2008-09-02T02:20
at 2008-09-02T02:20
By Gilbert
at 2008-09-07T01:55
at 2008-09-07T01:55
By Adele
at 2008-09-10T07:54
at 2008-09-10T07:54
By Damian
at 2008-09-14T08:33
at 2008-09-14T08:33
By Dorothy
at 2008-09-18T10:25
at 2008-09-18T10:25
By Noah
at 2008-09-20T23:10
at 2008-09-20T23:10
By Dinah
at 2008-09-21T19:36
at 2008-09-21T19:36
By Susan
at 2008-09-23T20:18
at 2008-09-23T20:18
By Elizabeth
at 2008-09-27T06:02
at 2008-09-27T06:02
By Blanche
at 2008-09-28T17:47
at 2008-09-28T17:47
By Carolina Franco
at 2008-09-30T23:02
at 2008-09-30T23:02
By Ula
at 2008-10-03T02:59
at 2008-10-03T02:59
By Emily
at 2008-10-04T13:23
at 2008-10-04T13:23
By Mia
at 2008-10-08T16:44
at 2008-10-08T16:44
By Iris
at 2008-10-13T03:33
at 2008-10-13T03:33
By Rae
at 2008-10-16T08:49
at 2008-10-16T08:49
By Elizabeth
at 2008-10-16T20:36
at 2008-10-16T20:36
By Elizabeth
at 2008-10-19T17:54
at 2008-10-19T17:54
By Yuri
at 2008-10-21T08:51
at 2008-10-21T08:51
By Lauren
at 2008-10-25T14:28
at 2008-10-25T14:28
By Rosalind
at 2008-10-26T12:39
at 2008-10-26T12:39
By Yuri
at 2008-10-26T17:40
at 2008-10-26T17:40
By Bennie
at 2008-10-28T00:44
at 2008-10-28T00:44
By Hedwig
at 2008-10-31T16:42
at 2008-10-31T16:42
By Eartha
at 2008-11-05T03:01
at 2008-11-05T03:01
By Puput
at 2008-11-08T07:50
at 2008-11-08T07:50
By Caroline
at 2008-11-10T01:27
at 2008-11-10T01:27
By Anonymous
at 2008-11-13T08:57
at 2008-11-13T08:57
By Elvira
at 2008-11-13T20:17
at 2008-11-13T20:17
By Linda
at 2008-11-17T18:28
at 2008-11-17T18:28
By Queena
at 2008-11-20T00:30
at 2008-11-20T00:30
By Selena
at 2008-11-22T01:28
at 2008-11-22T01:28
By Megan
at 2008-11-26T16:45
at 2008-11-26T16:45
By Donna
at 2008-11-29T23:37
at 2008-11-29T23:37
By Donna
at 2008-11-30T12:15
at 2008-11-30T12:15
By Ingrid
at 2008-12-04T02:14
at 2008-12-04T02:14
By Ingrid
at 2008-12-08T12:29
at 2008-12-08T12:29
By Poppy
at 2008-12-09T03:04
at 2008-12-09T03:04
By Joe
at 2008-12-12T00:48
at 2008-12-12T00:48
By Irma
at 2008-12-12T08:06
at 2008-12-12T08:06
By Edwina
at 2008-12-15T02:30
at 2008-12-15T02:30
By Emily
at 2008-12-19T15:44
at 2008-12-19T15:44
By Eartha
at 2008-12-23T23:05
at 2008-12-23T23:05
By Emily
at 2008-12-24T06:43
at 2008-12-24T06:43
By Mia
at 2008-12-27T20:29
at 2008-12-27T20:29
By Kumar
at 2008-12-29T11:20
at 2008-12-29T11:20
By Kelly
at 2009-01-01T06:28
at 2009-01-01T06:28
By Joe
at 2009-01-04T13:20
at 2009-01-04T13:20
By Madame
at 2009-01-06T10:25
at 2009-01-06T10:25
By Kumar
at 2009-01-08T15:37
at 2009-01-08T15:37
By Irma
at 2009-01-10T17:52
at 2009-01-10T17:52
By Gary
at 2009-01-11T00:53
at 2009-01-11T00:53
By Kumar
at 2009-01-13T15:45
at 2009-01-13T15:45
By Jessica
at 2009-01-15T17:09
at 2009-01-15T17:09
By Elma
at 2009-01-16T09:58
at 2009-01-16T09:58
By Puput
at 2009-01-17T14:51
at 2009-01-17T14:51
By Ina
at 2009-01-20T14:36
at 2009-01-20T14:36
By Olga
at 2009-01-25T01:39
at 2009-01-25T01:39
By Dorothy
at 2009-01-25T22:34
at 2009-01-25T22:34
By Aaliyah
at 2009-01-26T14:36
at 2009-01-26T14:36
By Selena
at 2009-01-27T07:11
at 2009-01-27T07:11
By Isla
at 2009-01-28T11:09
at 2009-01-28T11:09
By Noah
at 2009-01-29T22:41
at 2009-01-29T22:41
By Lauren
at 2009-01-30T18:33
at 2009-01-30T18:33
By Jessica
at 2009-02-03T21:45
at 2009-02-03T21:45
By Kristin
at 2009-02-06T17:12
at 2009-02-06T17:12
By Sandy
at 2009-02-11T07:11
at 2009-02-11T07:11
By Callum
at 2009-02-15T22:02
at 2009-02-15T22:02
By Harry
at 2009-02-16T23:59
at 2009-02-16T23:59
By Catherine
at 2009-02-19T06:24
at 2009-02-19T06:24
By Ivy
at 2009-02-22T02:19
at 2009-02-22T02:19
By Doris
at 2009-02-24T22:40
at 2009-02-24T22:40
By Quanna
at 2009-03-01T16:39
at 2009-03-01T16:39
By Jessica
at 2009-03-04T09:53
at 2009-03-04T09:53
By Belly
at 2009-03-09T07:28
at 2009-03-09T07:28
By Susan
at 2009-03-12T20:23
at 2009-03-12T20:23
By Damian
at 2009-03-16T06:42
at 2009-03-16T06:42
By Jacob
at 2009-03-16T12:29
at 2009-03-16T12:29
By Quanna
at 2009-03-17T13:36
at 2009-03-17T13:36
By Mia
at 2009-03-19T15:50
at 2009-03-19T15:50
By Enid
at 2009-03-20T16:22
at 2009-03-20T16:22
By Zenobia
at 2009-03-23T15:12
at 2009-03-23T15:12
By Kristin
at 2009-03-26T10:00
at 2009-03-26T10:00
By Kristin
at 2009-03-30T23:21
at 2009-03-30T23:21
By Robert
at 2009-04-03T09:40
at 2009-04-03T09:40
By Olive
at 2009-04-07T16:09
at 2009-04-07T16:09
By Doris
at 2009-04-09T07:22
at 2009-04-09T07:22
By Lucy
at 2009-04-14T01:22
at 2009-04-14T01:22
By Odelette
at 2009-04-15T13:01
at 2009-04-15T13:01
By Yedda
at 2009-04-19T09:53
at 2009-04-19T09:53
By Blanche
at 2009-04-23T05:03
at 2009-04-23T05:03
By Andy
at 2009-04-25T05:26
at 2009-04-25T05:26
By Lydia
at 2009-04-28T19:52
at 2009-04-28T19:52
By Vanessa
at 2009-05-01T03:00
at 2009-05-01T03:00
By Bennie
at 2009-05-02T08:19
at 2009-05-02T08:19
By Xanthe
at 2009-05-06T17:10
at 2009-05-06T17:10
By Michael
at 2009-05-07T04:42
at 2009-05-07T04:42
By Catherine
at 2009-05-08T17:19
at 2009-05-08T17:19
By Rachel
at 2009-05-13T03:28
at 2009-05-13T03:28
By Anonymous
at 2009-05-14T22:57
at 2009-05-14T22:57
Related Posts
單身女子入境加拿大
By Cara
at 2008-05-07T01:13
at 2008-05-07T01:13
多倫多生活問題
By David
at 2008-05-06T14:09
at 2008-05-06T14:09
轉學到U of T的St. George...
By Tom
at 2008-05-06T13:01
at 2008-05-06T13:01
請問加拿大內陸機票
By Anonymous
at 2008-05-05T23:21
at 2008-05-05T23:21
在卡加利機場換錢
By Ina
at 2008-05-05T17:45
at 2008-05-05T17:45