[論卦] 加拿大不承認台灣是中國領土的理由 - 加拿大

Zora avatar
By Zora
at 2008-05-07T13:06

Table of Contents

※ [本文轉錄自 Gossiping 看板]

作者: ohfly (像個小孩子) 看板: Gossiping
標題: [論卦] 加拿大不承認台灣是中國領土的理由
時間: Wed May 7 12:09:08 2008

加拿大, 全球政治最清廉的國家之一
加拿大外交部的回答讓我們不得不佩服....

長久以來,中國一直堅持台灣是中國的一部份。但是在60年代,中共便為此鬧了個國際笑
話。中國外交部要求加拿大承認台灣是中國的領土。加拿大提出5點理由反駁﹕


(一)台灣並非加拿大所擁有之領土,所以加拿大沒有權利承認台灣主權歸屬於誰。
如果是加拿大所擁有的北極圈諸小島與中國有爭議,加拿大才有權利承認其歸屬。這是從
羅馬法以來的所有權法理。國際法當然也依此原則適用。



(二)沒有任何國際法理論使加拿大有「權利」承認、或有「義務」承認與它無任何關係
的台灣的主權歸屬。中國要求加拿大做這種承認毫無道理。



(三)即使加拿大承認台灣是中國一部份,實際上並無任何法效果或意義。因為加拿大國
民、飛機、船舶要進入台灣,拿北京政權所發簽證根本無效,還是要向台灣當局申請簽證
。承認其對台灣實效統治,這等於是立刻又以具體行為否認台灣是中國的一部份。



(四)加拿大若在國際條約中承認台灣是中國的一部份,依條約必須履行原理,加拿大勢
必派兵攻佔台灣,負責把台灣交給中國以履行條約。這是多麼荒謬的一件事。



(五)台灣如果的確屬於中國,則北京政權又何必要求各國承認。例如,海南島是中國領
土不可分割的一部份,中國根本不必要求他國承認。反之,台灣若非中國領土,中國即使
到處去要求他國承認,實際上也沒有國際法效果。如果台灣是有紛爭的領土,中國也應該
去找與該領土有關的當事國交涉及承認才有國際法效果。強迫無關的第三國承認是毫無意
義。

說得中國外交部啞口無言,十億口莫辨。自此之後,中國只能嘴巴嚷嚷,不敢再要求加拿
大承認台灣是中國的領土。

論理充分...提出理由的加拿大外交部老兄顯然受過嚴謹邏輯訓練... ...


--

All Comments

Daph Bay avatar
By Daph Bay
at 2008-05-11T02:18
看標題先推 不推不是人
Jessica avatar
By Jessica
at 2008-05-15T15:29
這個好猛
Edward Lewis avatar
By Edward Lewis
at 2008-05-19T20:19
加拿大人好猛呀!!
Edwina avatar
By Edwina
at 2008-05-23T05:00
我的推用掉了...誰來幫我推一下
Daniel avatar
By Daniel
at 2008-05-23T19:54
請各位承認志玲是我的老婆
Eden avatar
By Eden
at 2008-05-27T14:20
不推..我只記得那一場外卡賽..
Andrew avatar
By Andrew
at 2008-05-27T17:26
i love canada
Lily avatar
By Lily
at 2008-05-28T12:36
請各位承認志玲是我的老婆
Susan avatar
By Susan
at 2008-05-28T19:08
推阿 加拿大真的是讚
Rae avatar
By Rae
at 2008-06-02T14:47
GOOD
William avatar
By William
at 2008-06-04T05:42
那是60年代的事了...
Rae avatar
By Rae
at 2008-06-06T23:15
總覺得這篇看過N次了....
Genevieve avatar
By Genevieve
at 2008-06-08T14:14
雖然是萬年回鍋 不過看的還是很爽
Jake avatar
By Jake
at 2008-06-10T03:45
那我還得負責把志玲打暈,塗個KY再送到你床上囉?
Skylar Davis avatar
By Skylar Davis
at 2008-06-11T10:55
請各位承認志玲是我的老婆
Daniel avatar
By Daniel
at 2008-06-11T15:29
love canada
Carolina Franco avatar
By Carolina Franco
at 2008-06-11T16:34
會有蟲蟲說也沒建交 屁話一堆
Ina avatar
By Ina
at 2008-06-14T19:06
請各位承認郭靜是我的細姨。
Xanthe avatar
By Xanthe
at 2008-06-18T02:00
BB
Rachel avatar
By Rachel
at 2008-06-19T21:15
蟲:也沒建交阿 屁話一堆
Olive avatar
By Olive
at 2008-06-22T16:31
Linda avatar
By Linda
at 2008-06-25T11:27
Love letter from Canada~~~阿~~嘶──────
Quintina avatar
By Quintina
at 2008-06-26T09:11
這梗很老了......
Eartha avatar
By Eartha
at 2008-06-26T16:05
護航大軍怎麼還沒來.......
Ina avatar
By Ina
at 2008-06-30T19:36
我只記得奧運資格賽加拿大撞二壘手跟捕手
Hedwig avatar
By Hedwig
at 2008-07-03T06:11
剛剛摸奶奶貼了什麼又自D阿?
Victoria avatar
By Victoria
at 2008-07-04T02:58
非常贊同第三點~~~XD
Kumar avatar
By Kumar
at 2008-07-08T16:23
請各位承認志玲是我的老婆 +1
Liam avatar
By Liam
at 2008-07-09T18:38
好像很久以前的故事了= =
Rachel avatar
By Rachel
at 2008-07-11T08:53
他貼ㄧ行文
Olive avatar
By Olive
at 2008-07-12T07:41
那現在呢......?
Brianna avatar
By Brianna
at 2008-07-16T18:22
很屌很長大。
Noah avatar
By Noah
at 2008-07-19T10:29
玲,一堆人要我承認你是他老婆耶,妳要不要放開我的30CM
Anonymous avatar
By Anonymous
at 2008-07-21T04:32
推 love letter from Canada~~~~~~~~
Anonymous avatar
By Anonymous
at 2008-07-23T17:22
表示一下意見??
Frederica avatar
By Frederica
at 2008-07-27T11:47
lag很久了
Annie avatar
By Annie
at 2008-07-29T04:40
台肯!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Isabella avatar
By Isabella
at 2008-08-01T02:53
有出處或來源嗎
Catherine avatar
By Catherine
at 2008-08-05T08:32
好像有點久遠囉~
Harry avatar
By Harry
at 2008-08-09T07:23
推加拿大外交官XDDDD
Kyle avatar
By Kyle
at 2008-08-10T16:35
Ida avatar
By Ida
at 2008-08-12T01:29
推這篇!!雖然看過幾次了:)
Liam avatar
By Liam
at 2008-08-15T08:24
XD
Michael avatar
By Michael
at 2008-08-19T06:35
礙國銅芯穢: 怒~~~~~~~!
Yuri avatar
By Yuri
at 2008-08-19T23:35
推阿 大陸是台灣不可分割的神聖領土
Eartha avatar
By Eartha
at 2008-08-20T23:16
推!!
Valerie avatar
By Valerie
at 2008-08-24T08:45
來源就是太多來源 我也找不到來源了 本文給沒看過的人看
Lauren avatar
By Lauren
at 2008-08-26T04:05
來源不是重點,重點是下載速度.....((誤
Elma avatar
By Elma
at 2008-08-28T17:15
= =
Sarah avatar
By Sarah
at 2008-09-02T02:20
這第4點好好笑 XDDDDDDDDD
Gilbert avatar
By Gilbert
at 2008-09-07T01:55
這年頭只要以經貿要脅 引再多法理也沒用
Adele avatar
By Adele
at 2008-09-10T07:54
60年代的老調重彈
Damian avatar
By Damian
at 2008-09-14T08:33
topsniper 哈 有幽默到 我這篇下載了30年多年才下載好XDDD
Dorothy avatar
By Dorothy
at 2008-09-18T10:25
Noah avatar
By Noah
at 2008-09-20T23:10
================60年代就這麼中肯了=================
Dinah avatar
By Dinah
at 2008-09-21T19:36
不知道過了那麼久 支那想出反駁的方法沒
Susan avatar
By Susan
at 2008-09-23T20:18
反駁:"阿管你那麼多,反正我們贏兩百萬票啦~公投沒過啦~"
Elizabeth avatar
By Elizabeth
at 2008-09-27T06:02
這個以前就看過了
Blanche avatar
By Blanche
at 2008-09-28T17:47
推樓上
Carolina Franco avatar
By Carolina Franco
at 2008-09-30T23:02
推阿
Ula avatar
By Ula
at 2008-10-03T02:59
嗯.........好像是7 8個月前的 op
Emily avatar
By Emily
at 2008-10-04T13:23
推這篇!
Mia avatar
By Mia
at 2008-10-08T16:44
統派快來噓這篇
Iris avatar
By Iris
at 2008-10-13T03:33
加拿大的皇家騎警會拿電擊棒把阿陸仔電到吱吱叫
Rae avatar
By Rae
at 2008-10-16T08:49
Elizabeth avatar
By Elizabeth
at 2008-10-16T20:36
啊 主流民意好像是要統一喲.....
Elizabeth avatar
By Elizabeth
at 2008-10-19T17:54
傷當第中肯!
Yuri avatar
By Yuri
at 2008-10-21T08:51
統派:發動抵制加拿大 抵制加貨
Lauren avatar
By Lauren
at 2008-10-25T14:28
加拿大:科科
Rosalind avatar
By Rosalind
at 2008-10-26T12:39
OP很久了...
Yuri avatar
By Yuri
at 2008-10-26T17:40
很久以前就看過這文章一直不知道他的真實性如何?還是人家
KUSO出來的?
Bennie avatar
By Bennie
at 2008-10-28T00:44
XD 中國就愛搞這些 "喂喂 你說台灣是不是我們偉大祖國的?"
Hedwig avatar
By Hedwig
at 2008-10-31T16:42
滿分!
Eartha avatar
By Eartha
at 2008-11-05T03:01
"喂喂 你說台灣是不是我們偉大祖國的?"
Puput avatar
By Puput
at 2008-11-08T07:50
南海血衣才是真的阿 哈哈
Caroline avatar
By Caroline
at 2008-11-10T01:27
Anonymous avatar
By Anonymous
at 2008-11-13T08:57
阮天仇
Elvira avatar
By Elvira
at 2008-11-13T20:17
想當初8搶3 大家罵成一片... 現在因為一篇文被推
Linda avatar
By Linda
at 2008-11-17T18:28
這個是偽物... 而且 op很久了
Queena avatar
By Queena
at 2008-11-20T00:30
鄉民果然很好煽動
Selena avatar
By Selena
at 2008-11-22T01:28
"喂喂 你說台灣是不是我們偉大祖國的?"
Megan avatar
By Megan
at 2008-11-26T16:45
這加拿大外交部好萌(?
Donna avatar
By Donna
at 2008-11-29T23:37
又要爆啦~~~~
Donna avatar
By Donna
at 2008-11-30T12:15
加拿大好屌(Y)
Ingrid avatar
By Ingrid
at 2008-12-04T02:14
怎麼沒人來護航 XD
Ingrid avatar
By Ingrid
at 2008-12-08T12:29
統派們 大膽的護航吧 想跟中國統一並不可恥阿
Poppy avatar
By Poppy
at 2008-12-09T03:04
棒球比賽罵的東西跟這篇文讚賞的東西 我想鄉民還懂得分辨
Joe avatar
By Joe
at 2008-12-12T00:48
===============南方公園?
Irma avatar
By Irma
at 2008-12-12T08:06
可能king5312分不太出來~.~
Edwina avatar
By Edwina
at 2008-12-15T02:30
不過有些人分不出來 唉~
Emily avatar
By Emily
at 2008-12-19T15:44
棒球比賽跟這有何關連 哈 怎會聯想在一起ㄋ
Eartha avatar
By Eartha
at 2008-12-23T23:05
GOOD JOB
Emily avatar
By Emily
at 2008-12-24T06:43
有的人就愛混為一談....
Mia avatar
By Mia
at 2008-12-27T20:29
把球賽輸贏跟國家主權兩者拿來類比 鄉民的腦袋還真簡單
Kumar avatar
By Kumar
at 2008-12-29T11:20
有一次支那足球比賽輸給日本 有支那人暴動高喊還我釣魚台
Kelly avatar
By Kelly
at 2009-01-01T06:28
5312想酸失敗 29
Joe avatar
By Joe
at 2009-01-04T13:20
強啊!
Madame avatar
By Madame
at 2009-01-06T10:25
push啦 這加拿大佬比支那犬聰明多了
Kumar avatar
By Kumar
at 2009-01-08T15:37
之前看過就覺得超猛!!!
Irma avatar
By Irma
at 2009-01-10T17:52
那我待在加拿大是值得了XD
Gary avatar
By Gary
at 2009-01-11T00:53
這種話要想出來不難 只是加拿大比較有種跟中國說no
Kumar avatar
By Kumar
at 2009-01-13T15:45
好好玩喔
Jessica avatar
By Jessica
at 2009-01-15T17:09
這是很簡單的邏輯~兩岸問題若當作內政議題他國不得干預
Elma avatar
By Elma
at 2009-01-16T09:58
抱持的懷疑的態度 ...
Puput avatar
By Puput
at 2009-01-17T14:51
推法理辯證 帥啦
Ina avatar
By Ina
at 2009-01-20T14:36
妳們這樣奉承對得起葉君璋嗎
Olga avatar
By Olga
at 2009-01-25T01:39
好棒!!
Dorothy avatar
By Dorothy
at 2009-01-25T22:34
good job
Aaliyah avatar
By Aaliyah
at 2009-01-26T14:36
這板上有人欠葉君璋錢嗎?
Selena avatar
By Selena
at 2009-01-27T07:11
推你一個加拿大
Isla avatar
By Isla
at 2009-01-28T11:09
原來棒球比賽和國際外交是同一件事情啊 受教了~
Noah avatar
By Noah
at 2009-01-29T22:41
就事論事 對事不對人 這兩件事幹嘛混為一談?
Lauren avatar
By Lauren
at 2009-01-30T18:33
請各位承認志玲是我的老婆
Jessica avatar
By Jessica
at 2009-02-03T21:45
幾年前就有的東西吧
Kristin avatar
By Kristin
at 2009-02-06T17:12
XDDDD
Sandy avatar
By Sandy
at 2009-02-11T07:11
爽!
Callum avatar
By Callum
at 2009-02-15T22:02
加拿大魂
Harry avatar
By Harry
at 2009-02-16T23:59
GJ
Catherine avatar
By Catherine
at 2009-02-19T06:24
yo~ yo~ 給我一點tempo~
Ivy avatar
By Ivy
at 2009-02-22T02:19
GJ 好爽唷
Doris avatar
By Doris
at 2009-02-24T22:40
哈哈哈 超妙的
Quanna avatar
By Quanna
at 2009-03-01T16:39
加拿大魂!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
Jessica avatar
By Jessica
at 2009-03-04T09:53
GJ!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Belly avatar
By Belly
at 2009-03-09T07:28
決定去辦楓葉卡 XD
Susan avatar
By Susan
at 2009-03-12T20:23
中肯到爆
Damian avatar
By Damian
at 2009-03-16T06:42
推加拿大
Jacob avatar
By Jacob
at 2009-03-16T12:29
99
Quanna avatar
By Quanna
at 2009-03-17T13:36
雖然很早以前就看過了 但是幫推 爆
Mia avatar
By Mia
at 2009-03-19T15:50
八搶三的時候,這篇文章應該會被噓
Enid avatar
By Enid
at 2009-03-20T16:22
所以? 一直提八搶三來模糊焦點很爽? 重點在這篇內容啊
Zenobia avatar
By Zenobia
at 2009-03-23T15:12
看了還是很爽
Kristin avatar
By Kristin
at 2009-03-26T10:00
不推不是台灣人!!
Kristin avatar
By Kristin
at 2009-03-30T23:21
我想推XDDD
Robert avatar
By Robert
at 2009-04-03T09:40
一定要推~~這篇文章超中肯的!!大推
Olive avatar
By Olive
at 2009-04-07T16:09
讚!! 難得有說話誠懇的國家!! 有種!!!
Doris avatar
By Doris
at 2009-04-09T07:22
可是不是有版友的學校不讓他們國籍寫台灣??
Lucy avatar
By Lucy
at 2009-04-14T01:22
推推推
Odelette avatar
By Odelette
at 2009-04-15T13:01
推 但是學校還是在Taiwan後面補上Province of China...
Yedda avatar
By Yedda
at 2009-04-19T09:53
數字版權限不足 來這邊推..
Blanche avatar
By Blanche
at 2009-04-23T05:03
Canadians: why do we need communists in Canada?
Andy avatar
By Andy
at 2009-04-25T05:26
版友的學校,負責人好像是中國人啊(?)
Lydia avatar
By Lydia
at 2009-04-28T19:52
有看有推!
Vanessa avatar
By Vanessa
at 2009-05-01T03:00
偷偷提醒 這篇文章很老了:P
Bennie avatar
By Bennie
at 2009-05-02T08:19
Eddie版友指的版友是我嗎@@? 我說的學校是SFU~
Xanthe avatar
By Xanthe
at 2009-05-06T17:10
另外也同意limit的說法 之前就有看過這篇文章~
Michael avatar
By Michael
at 2009-05-07T04:42
有人找的道這篇加拿大方面的source嗎?
Catherine avatar
By Catherine
at 2009-05-08T17:19
不知道是否是真的官方回應 還是只是東湊西湊出來的
Rachel avatar
By Rachel
at 2009-05-13T03:28
my friend(Canadian) say Canada is LOVE & PEACE
Anonymous avatar
By Anonymous
at 2009-05-14T22:57
讚啦~難怪我這麼喜歡加拿大..現在在Hamilton,ON

單身女子入境加拿大

Cara avatar
By Cara
at 2008-05-07T01:13
1.其實兩個都可以 2.建議你說停留一個星期就好,比較不會對你囉唆 3.500是OK的 4.就填一星期就可以,因為不管你填多久,你都可以停留半年, 只要不超 ...

多倫多生活問題

David avatar
By David
at 2008-05-06T14:09
請問一下 過幾天要去多倫多開會 在metro toronto convention centre開會 住在89 chestnut residence hotel 想要買藥品跟維他命 哪裡買比較便宜又方便?! 從多倫多�� ...

轉學到U of T的St. George...

Tom avatar
By Tom
at 2008-05-06T13:01
※ 引述《lookinforyou (Loving Kitty =))》之銘言: : 我現在在申請轉學 : 要轉到St. George的Accurial Science讀 : 可是有點擔心會轉不過去 andgt;and#34;andlt; : 所以上來 ...

請問加拿大內陸機票

Anonymous avatar
By Anonymous
at 2008-05-05T23:21
十一月要去加拿大玩 大概11/7要從多倫多附近飛到溫哥華 但是上網查機票最便宜的都要四百多加幣 westjet的 不知道還有沒有便宜的訂票方式 我有看到 ...

在卡加利機場換錢

Ina avatar
By Ina
at 2008-05-05T17:45
※ 引述《phoebe02 (哪裡拆書可以現好)》之銘言: : 我5月要去卡家利 : 想要拿歐元到當地再換 : 請問機場換錢方便嗎?! : 或是banff國家公園有地方可以�� ...