中國人/華人的民族自尊心很強? - 文化差異
By Hedda
at 2009-10-10T13:53
at 2009-10-10T13:53
Table of Contents
不是討戰,只是持平討論現象
人常說韓國人自尊心很強
但中國人/華人民族自尊心的表現更在韓國人之上
尤其中國向來自稱天朝,稱鄰國為蠻夷,對西方人總是洋人洋鬼子的叫
歷代都是「上國」,近百年被西方列強超越,自尊心融合自卑心更形成複雜的情結
超英趕美的強國夢是沒落貴族不服富豪平民的情結嗎?
說得更明白一點,強國夢不是為了與世界各國平起平坐,而是恢復凌駕諸國的歷史光榮?
最渴望恢復的民族光榮,是侵佔鄰國領土的漢唐盛世
最亟欲討回的民族屈辱,卻是被鄰國侵佔的對日戰爭
明明中土就被蒙古帝國、清帝國給滅了,卻愛把被外族滅掉的時間劃為中國的正朔朝代
也有人說:好在二戰最後靠著美國原子彈贏了,
不然中國史學家可能又得想辦法把被日本統治的時期劃為中國的其中一個朝代
最近新加坡發現不少取得新加坡永久居民的中國人依舊效忠中國
例如放下在新加坡的工作跑回北京徵選十一國慶女兵
移民到全世界各地的中國人,除了接受當地教育的第二三代漸漸接受該國認同以外
移民還是自稱中國人,並以身為中國人為豪
某市長時期編印的英文版《台北導覽》竟提醒外國遊客:
「如果叫戰後來台的外省人『台灣人』,他們會覺得不太舒服」。
(即使這多少也與統治者vs被統治者的地位高低有關)
不可否認,檢視我自己,也有這種身為華人的榮耀感
另外,這篇文章也舉了不少例子
http://wefong.com/bbs/archiver/?tid-1940531.html
我推測世界各地華僑依舊自稱中國人、以及台灣的認同爭議
一部份原因與中國人的自尊心--「不願成為不如中華民族的外邦人」有關?
此篇的重點不在針砭這種自尊心榮耀感是好是壞,只討論這種現象的實例與影響
各位的看法如何?歡迎討論
--
︻ 一、當有用不到的東西時 二、不妨捐給需要的人 三、可以得到更大的快樂
公 ′ 嗯... ^ ^ > < 好冷.. 。。 超人? ‵′ 噠啦
益 _ S ▽ /S ﹏ ▃ ▽
原 █╯ ▼ /█ ▼ ∞ █╯ <S>
理 || ╯\ << || /\
︼ 怎麼走?市民廣場 → 3.PttAction → 3.PttActivity → 3.Ptt-Charity 公益版 作好事最快樂 作好事最快樂 作好事最快樂 作好事最快樂 作好事最快樂 作好事最快樂
--
人常說韓國人自尊心很強
但中國人/華人民族自尊心的表現更在韓國人之上
尤其中國向來自稱天朝,稱鄰國為蠻夷,對西方人總是洋人洋鬼子的叫
歷代都是「上國」,近百年被西方列強超越,自尊心融合自卑心更形成複雜的情結
超英趕美的強國夢是沒落貴族不服富豪平民的情結嗎?
說得更明白一點,強國夢不是為了與世界各國平起平坐,而是恢復凌駕諸國的歷史光榮?
最渴望恢復的民族光榮,是侵佔鄰國領土的漢唐盛世
最亟欲討回的民族屈辱,卻是被鄰國侵佔的對日戰爭
明明中土就被蒙古帝國、清帝國給滅了,卻愛把被外族滅掉的時間劃為中國的正朔朝代
也有人說:好在二戰最後靠著美國原子彈贏了,
不然中國史學家可能又得想辦法把被日本統治的時期劃為中國的其中一個朝代
最近新加坡發現不少取得新加坡永久居民的中國人依舊效忠中國
例如放下在新加坡的工作跑回北京徵選十一國慶女兵
移民到全世界各地的中國人,除了接受當地教育的第二三代漸漸接受該國認同以外
移民還是自稱中國人,並以身為中國人為豪
某市長時期編印的英文版《台北導覽》竟提醒外國遊客:
「如果叫戰後來台的外省人『台灣人』,他們會覺得不太舒服」。
(即使這多少也與統治者vs被統治者的地位高低有關)
不可否認,檢視我自己,也有這種身為華人的榮耀感
另外,這篇文章也舉了不少例子
http://wefong.com/bbs/archiver/?tid-1940531.html
我推測世界各地華僑依舊自稱中國人、以及台灣的認同爭議
一部份原因與中國人的自尊心--「不願成為不如中華民族的外邦人」有關?
此篇的重點不在針砭這種自尊心榮耀感是好是壞,只討論這種現象的實例與影響
各位的看法如何?歡迎討論
--
︻ 一、當有用不到的東西時 二、不妨捐給需要的人 三、可以得到更大的快樂
公 ′ 嗯... ^ ^ > < 好冷.. 。。 超人? ‵′ 噠啦
益 _ S ▽ /S ﹏ ▃ ▽
原 █╯ ▼ /█ ▼ ∞ █╯ <S>
理 || ╯\ << || /\
︼ 怎麼走?市民廣場 → 3.PttAction → 3.PttActivity → 3.Ptt-Charity 公益版 作好事最快樂 作好事最快樂 作好事最快樂 作好事最快樂 作好事最快樂 作好事最快樂
--
Tags:
文化差異
All Comments
By Liam
at 2009-10-14T04:10
at 2009-10-14T04:10
By Noah
at 2009-10-17T13:09
at 2009-10-17T13:09
By Blanche
at 2009-10-22T06:23
at 2009-10-22T06:23
By Connor
at 2009-10-24T21:28
at 2009-10-24T21:28
By Isla
at 2009-10-25T03:46
at 2009-10-25T03:46
By Ida
at 2009-10-29T05:59
at 2009-10-29T05:59
By Caitlin
at 2009-10-29T23:52
at 2009-10-29T23:52
By Sarah
at 2009-10-31T06:35
at 2009-10-31T06:35
By Kristin
at 2009-11-01T21:06
at 2009-11-01T21:06
By Yuri
at 2009-11-04T22:44
at 2009-11-04T22:44
By Agnes
at 2009-11-08T18:27
at 2009-11-08T18:27
By Ursula
at 2009-11-10T17:22
at 2009-11-10T17:22
By Vanessa
at 2009-11-11T17:41
at 2009-11-11T17:41
By Emily
at 2009-11-13T15:05
at 2009-11-13T15:05
By Blanche
at 2009-11-17T14:06
at 2009-11-17T14:06
By Madame
at 2009-11-19T18:00
at 2009-11-19T18:00
By Valerie
at 2009-11-24T05:27
at 2009-11-24T05:27
By Hazel
at 2009-11-25T12:24
at 2009-11-25T12:24
By Hazel
at 2009-11-27T09:19
at 2009-11-27T09:19
By Jake
at 2009-11-28T12:05
at 2009-11-28T12:05
By Queena
at 2009-11-29T00:35
at 2009-11-29T00:35
By Brianna
at 2009-11-30T19:10
at 2009-11-30T19:10
By Gary
at 2009-12-04T21:01
at 2009-12-04T21:01
By Aaliyah
at 2009-12-06T08:37
at 2009-12-06T08:37
By Elvira
at 2009-12-09T08:23
at 2009-12-09T08:23
By Kelly
at 2009-12-12T03:24
at 2009-12-12T03:24
By Hedwig
at 2009-12-15T02:42
at 2009-12-15T02:42
By Kama
at 2009-12-15T13:29
at 2009-12-15T13:29
By Skylar Davis
at 2009-12-20T05:04
at 2009-12-20T05:04
By Linda
at 2009-12-23T04:07
at 2009-12-23T04:07
By Zenobia
at 2009-12-25T16:05
at 2009-12-25T16:05
By Queena
at 2009-12-26T01:38
at 2009-12-26T01:38
By Annie
at 2009-12-29T17:26
at 2009-12-29T17:26
By Una
at 2010-01-02T21:48
at 2010-01-02T21:48
By Rosalind
at 2010-01-06T04:33
at 2010-01-06T04:33
By Victoria
at 2010-01-08T02:10
at 2010-01-08T02:10
By Kelly
at 2010-01-08T19:37
at 2010-01-08T19:37
By Ula
at 2010-01-13T01:33
at 2010-01-13T01:33
By Margaret
at 2010-01-17T08:36
at 2010-01-17T08:36
By Skylar Davis
at 2010-01-21T15:18
at 2010-01-21T15:18
By Xanthe
at 2010-01-24T20:56
at 2010-01-24T20:56
By Bennie
at 2010-01-27T10:02
at 2010-01-27T10:02
By Joseph
at 2010-01-31T08:52
at 2010-01-31T08:52
By Carol
at 2010-02-04T00:30
at 2010-02-04T00:30
By Una
at 2010-02-07T13:21
at 2010-02-07T13:21
By George
at 2010-02-11T07:15
at 2010-02-11T07:15
By Dora
at 2010-02-12T18:57
at 2010-02-12T18:57
By Michael
at 2010-02-13T03:03
at 2010-02-13T03:03
By Elma
at 2010-02-15T17:12
at 2010-02-15T17:12
By Adele
at 2010-02-20T01:45
at 2010-02-20T01:45
By Charlie
at 2010-02-24T15:22
at 2010-02-24T15:22
By Doris
at 2010-02-25T08:14
at 2010-02-25T08:14
By Ingrid
at 2010-02-25T17:52
at 2010-02-25T17:52
By Harry
at 2010-02-27T05:04
at 2010-02-27T05:04
By Kyle
at 2010-03-02T17:49
at 2010-03-02T17:49
By Rebecca
at 2010-03-03T01:39
at 2010-03-03T01:39
By Joseph
at 2010-03-05T22:02
at 2010-03-05T22:02
Related Posts
Re: Are you Chinese?
By Wallis
at 2009-10-10T13:33
at 2009-10-10T13:33
Re: Are you Chinese?
By Agnes
at 2009-10-10T12:52
at 2009-10-10T12:52
Re: Are you Chinese?
By Ina
at 2009-10-10T12:51
at 2009-10-10T12:51
Re: Are you Chinese?
By Ursula
at 2009-10-10T12:40
at 2009-10-10T12:40
Re: Are you Chinese?
By Gilbert
at 2009-10-10T05:53
at 2009-10-10T05:53